«上一篇/Previous Article|本期目录/Table of Contents|下一篇/Next Article»

《长安大学学报（社科版）》[ISSN:1671-6248/CN:61-1391/C]

卷:

第24卷

期数:

2022年05期

页码:

23-37

栏目:

国际经济与贸易

出版日期:

2022-11-30

文章信息/Info

Title:

Basis of the U.S. dollar’s international monetary network effect:a review of the petrodollar system

文章编号:

1671-6248(2022)05-0023-15

作者:

余子良¹; 邙荟婷¹; 佟家栋²

(1. 南开大学 金融学院,天津 300350; 2. 南开大学 经济学院,天津 300071)

Author(s):

YU Ziliang¹;  MANG Huiting¹;  TONG Jiadong²

(1. School of Finance, Nankai University, Tianjin 300350, China; 2. School of Economics,Nankai University, Tianjin 300071, China)

关键词:

国际货币;  网络效应;  石油美元体系;  国际定价权;  人民币国际化

Keywords:

international currency;  network effect;  petrodollar system;  international pricing power;  RMB internationalization

分类号:

F821

DOI:

-

文献标志码:

A

摘要:

国际货币的网络效应是一国货币获得国际货币地位并得以维系的基础,网络效应从理论上解释了现行国际货币体系,但是当前网络效应产生的根本原因阐释仍然缺如。以石油美元为切入点,梳理石油美元体系形成的历史背景和过程,分析美国是如何通过对石油生产的控制,配合国内深度发达的金融市场,使得美元全面主导石油的计价权、定价权、交易媒介、结算货币、风险管理、富余资金投资等多个领域,从而形成了后布雷顿森林体系时期美元国际货币网络效应的基础; 进一步分析了石油美元体系潜在的脆弱性、近期涌现的石油贸易去美元化现象及其对人民币国际化的启示。研究认为,鉴于目前以石油美元体系等为基础所形成的网络效应,以美元为主导的现行国际金融体系在未来较长一段时间内仍将持续; 人民币国际化过程中应发展以人民币计价的原油期货等大宗商品衍生品市场,促进大宗商品计价、定价与贸易结算等人民币化,培育人民币使用的网络效应。

Abstract:

The network effect of international currencies is the basis for a country’s currency to gain and sustain international monetary status. However, while the network effect is a good theoretical explanation of the current international monetary system, it does not explain the underlying causes of the formation of the current network effect. Taking the petrodollar as the specific case, this paper summarizes the historical background and process of the formation of the petrodollar system, and analyzes how the U.S. dollar, through the control of oil production and deeply developed domestic financial market, has thoroughly dominated oil price denomination, pricing, medium of exchange, settlement, risk management, investment of surplus funds and other fields of crude oil, thus forming the basis of the international monetary network effect of the U.S. dollar in the post-Bretton Woods system. The paper then further analyzes the potential vulnerability of the petrodollar system, the emergence of the phenomenon of de-dollarization of oil trade in recent years, and its inspiration and reference to the internationalization of the Chinese RMB. The analysis suggests that, the current international financial system dominated by the U.S. dollar will continue for a long time in the future, given the network effect developed on the basis of the petrodollar system at present. In the process of RMB internationalization, commodity derivatives markets such as crude oil futures denominated in RMB should be developed to promote the RMBization of commodity pricing, pricing and trade settlement, in order to foster the network effect of the use of RMB.

参考文献/References:

[1] 盛斌,钱学锋,黄玖立,等.入世十年转型:中国对外贸易发展的回顾与前瞻[J].国际经济评论,2011(5):84-101,4.
[2]EICHENGREEN B,MEHL A,CHITU L.How global currencies work:past,present,and future[M].Princeton:Princeton University Press,2017.
[3]FLANDREAU M,JOBST C.The empirics of international currencies:network externalities,history and persistence[J].The economic journal,2009,119(537):643-664.
[4]FARHI E,MAGGIORI M.A model of the international monetary system[J].The quarterly journal of economics,2018,133(1):295-355.
[5]CLARK W.Petrodollar warfare:dollars, euros and the upcoming Iranian oil bourse[M].Gabriola Island:New Society Publisher,2005.
[6]MILEVA E,SIEGFRIED N.Oil market structure,network effects and the choice of currency for oil invoicing[J].Energy policy,2012,44:385-394.
[7]TAVLAS G.The international use of the US dollar:an optimum currency area perspective[J].World economy,1997,20(6):709-747.
[8]KRUGMAN P.Vehicle currencies and the structure of international exchange[J].Journal of money,credit & banking,1980,12(3):513-526.
[9]CAO L.Currency wars and the erosion of dollar hegemony[J].Michigan journal of international law,2016,38(1):57-118.
[10]YANG J,ZHOU Y.Return and volatility transmission between China’s and international crude oil futures markets:a first look[J].Journal of futures markets,2020,40(6):860-884.
[11]LI H,LIN S.Do emerging markets matter in the world oil pricing system?evidence of imported crude by China and India[J].Energy policy,2011,39(8):4624-4630.
[12]MATHEWS J,SELDEN M.China:The emergence of the Petroyuan and the challenge to US dollar hegemony[J].The Asia-Pacific journal,2018,16(22/23):1-12.
[13]NORRLOF C.Dollar hegemony:a power analysis[J].Review of international political economy,2014,21(5):1042-1070.
[14]SIDDIQUI K.The US dollar and the world economy:a critical review[J].Athens journal of business & economics,2020,6(1):21-44.
[15]孙海霞,杨玲玲.货币国际化进程影响因素研究——基于外汇储备职能的实证分析[J].上海财经大学学报,2010,12(6):81-88.
[16]BORDO M D.The Bretton Woods international monetary system:a historical overview[EB/OL].(1992-03-15)[2022-03-01].https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w4033/w4033.pdf.
[17]WIGHT D.The Petrodollar era and relations between the United States and the Middle East and North Africa,1969-1980[D].Irvine:UC Irvine,2014.
[18]DE CECCO M.The international gold standard:money and empire[M].London:Frances Pinter Publishers,1984.
[19]DAVID E.The hidden hand of American hegemony[M].New York:Cornell University Press,1999.
[20]ENGEL C.The international monetary system:forty years after Bretton Woods[J].Journal of monetary economics,1986,17:441-448.
[21]SALAMEH M G.Has the Petrodollar had its day?[EB/OL].(2015-06-24)[2022-05-21].https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=650006067081086028019083026008091000104031001088088078094101070102124112125118122027006025120062011037101125119031123098096099033081071019079114070090123121068008036051086069124084025002122070106024100107124022125095092123089026004087106101112126072&EXT=pdf&INDEX=TRUE.
[22]YERGIN D.The prize:the epic quest for oil,money & power[M].New York:Simon and Schuster,2011.
[23]CLEVELAND W,BUNTON M.A history of the modern Middle East[M].London:Routledge,2018.
[24]SKEET I.OPEC:twenty-five years of prices and politics[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1991.
[25]JONES T.America,oil,and war in the Middle East[J].The journal of American history,2012,99(1):208-218.
[26]ANDERSON I.Aramco,the United States,and Saudi Arabia[M].Princeton:Princeton University Press,2014.
[27]DUDLEY B.BP statistical review of world energy 2014[EB/OL].(2014-06-16)[2022-05-18].https://www.docin.com/p-1770000069.html.
[28]MORSE E.A new political economy of oil?[J].Journal of international affairs,1999(3):1-29.
[29]MOMANI B.Gulf cooperation council oil exporters and the future of the dollar[J].New political economy,2008,13(3):293-314.
[30]GARBADE K,SILBER W.Price movements and price discovery in futures and cash markets[J].The review of economics and statistics,1983(2):289-297.
[31]CHASSARD C,HALLIWELL M.NYMEX crude oil futures market:an analysis of its performance[M]. London:Oxford Institute for Energy Studies,1986.
[32]GULEN S.Regionalization in the world crude oil market:further evidence[J].The energy journal,1999,20(1):125-139.
[33]ZHANG Y,MA S.Exploring the dynamic price discov-ery,risk transfer and spillover among INE,WTI and Brent crude oil futures markets:evidence from the high-frequency data[J].International journal of finance & economics,2021,26(2):2414-2435.
[34]魏巍贤,林伯强.国内外石油价格波动性及其互动关系[J].经济研究,2007(12):130-141.
[35]金洪飞,金荦.国际石油价格对中国股票市场的影响——基于行业数据的经验分析[J].金融研究,2010(2):173-187.
[36]FATTOUH B.An anatomy of the crude oil pricing system[M].London:Oxford Institute for Energy Studies,2011.
[37]SMITH J.Inscrutable OPEC? behavioral tests of the cartel hypothesis[J].The energy journal,2005,26(1):51-82.
[38]KILIAN L,MURPHY D.The role of inventories and speculative trading in the global market for crude oil[J].Journal of applied econometrics,2014,29(3):454-478.
[39]MILEVA E,SIEGFRIED N.Oil market structure,network effects and the choice of currency for oil invoicing[J].Energy policy,2012,44:385-394.
[40]HAMILTON J.Oil and the macroeconomy since World War II[J].Journal of political economy,1983,91(2):228-248.
[41]HAMILTON J.What is an oil shock?[J].Journal of econometrics,2003,113(2):363-398.
[42]ELDER J,SERLETIS A.Oil price uncertainty[J].Journal of money,credit and banking,2010,42(6):1137-1159.
[43]HAMILTON J.Understanding crude oil prices[J].The energy journal,2009,30(2):1-44.
[44]LANG K,AUER B.The economic and financial properties of crude oil:a review[J].The North American journal of economics and finance,2020,52:1-45.
[45]TANG K,XIONG W.Index investment and the financialization of commodities[J].Financial analysts journal,2012,68(6):54-74.
[46]BLINDER A.The role of the dollar as an international currency[J].Eastern economic journal,1996,22(2):127-136.
[47]ITO H,CHINN M.The rise of the redback and the people’s republic of China’s capital account liberalization:an empirical analysis of the determinants of invoicing currencies[J].ADBI working paper,2014(10):1-47.
[48]MILEVA E,SIEGFRIED N.Oil market structure,network effects and the choice of currency for oil invoicing[J].ECB occasional paper,2007(77):385-394.
[49]HARTMANN P,PHILIPP H.Currency competition and foreign exchange markets:the dollar,the yen and the euro[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1998.
[50]王道平,范小云.现行的国际货币体系是否是全球经济失衡和金融危机的原因[J].世界经济,2011,34(1):52-72.
[51]张明.次贷危机对当前国际货币体系的冲击[J].世界经济与政治,2009(6):74-80,5.
[52]AREZKI R,HASANOV F.Global imbalances and petrodollars[J].The world economy,2013,36(2):213-232.
[53]中国社会科学院“国际金融危机与经济学理论反思”课题组,李向阳.国际金融危机与国际贸易、国际金融秩序的发展方向[J].经济研究,2009,44(11):47-54.
[54]朱民.改变未来的金融危机[J].国际金融研究,2009(5):4-6.
[55]朱太辉.美元环流、全球经济结构失衡和金融危机[J].国际金融研究,2010(10):37-45.
[56]CABALLERO R J,GOURINCHAS F.Financial crash,commodity prices,and global imbalances[J].Brookings papers on economic activity,2008(3):1-55.
[57]REY H.Dilemma not trilemma:the global financial cycle and monetary policy independence[J].National bureau of economic research,2015(5):1-42.
[58]李稻葵,梅松.美元M2紧缩诱发世界金融危机:金融危机的内外因论及其检验[J].世界经济,2009(4):15-26.
[59]AIZENMAN J,JINJARAK Y,PARK D.International reserves and swap lines:substitutes or complements?[J].International review of economics & finance,2011,20(1):5-18.
[60]FRANKEL J.Internationalization of the RMB and historical precedents[J].Journal of economic integration,2012,27(3):329-365.
[61]ROSE A,SPIEGEL M.Dollar illiquidity and central bank swap arrangements during the global financial crisis[J].Journal of international economics,2012,88(2):326-340.
[62]JI Q,ZHANG D.China’s crude oil futures:introduction and some stylized facts[J].Finance research letters,2019,28:376-380.
[63]PALAO F,PARDO á,ROIG M.Is the leadership of the Brent-WTI threatened by China’s new crude oil futures market?[EB/OL].(2021-11-23)[2022-05-18].https://d.wanfangdata.com.cn/periodical/a263cf1478b4fa407c7ab1c625733320.
[64]ZHANG Q,DI P,FARNOOSH A.Study on the impacts of Shanghai crude oil futures on global oil market and oil industry based on VECM and DAG models[EB/OL].(2021-10-16)[2022-05-18].https://ideas.repec.org/p/hal/journl/hal-03151102.html.https://www.docin.com/p-1770000069.html
[65]巴曙松,杨现领.货币锚的选择与退出:对最优货币规则的再考察[J].国际经济评论,2011(1):141-154.
[66]KAMEL M,WANG H.Petro-RMB?the oil trade and the internationalization of the renminbi[J].International affairs,2019,95(5):1131-1148.
[67]施训鹏,姬强,张大永.国际原油定价机制演化及其对我国原油期货的启示[J].环境经济研究,2018,3(3):121-134.
[68]JOHNSON J.Forbidden fruit:Russia’s uneasy relationship with the US dollar[J].Review of international political economy,2008,15(3):379-398.
[69]张健.中日俄石油期货市场发展与合作[J].俄罗斯东欧中亚研究,2019(4):127-140,158.
[70]DASH D,SETHI N,BAL D.Is the demand for crude oil inelastic for India? evidence from structural VAR analysis[J].Energy policy,2018,118:552-558.
[71]SHARMA S.Market efficiency between Indian & US crude oil future market[J].Procedia computer science,2017,122:1039-1046.
[72]徐东,张立宗,高永刚,等.对中国原油期货市场的几个认识误区——基于国际原油期货市场的发展[J].国际石油经济,2017,25(2):90-95.
[73]刘瑞.日本石油期货市场发展困境及其启示[J].国际石油经济,2015,23(8):75-81.
[74]HAYASHI F,PRESCOTT E.The 1990s in Japan:a lost decade[J].Review of economic dynamics,2002,5(1):206-235.
[75]NAKAJIMA T.Test for volatility spillover effects in Japan’s oil futures markets by a realized variance approach[J].Studies in economics and finance,2018,36(2):224-239.
[76]FAN J,ZHANG T.The untold story of commodity futures in China[J].Journal of futures markets,2020,40(4):671-706.
[77]YANG J,LI Z,WANG T.Price discovery in Chinese agricultural futures markets:a comprehensive look[J].Journal of futures markets,2021,41(4):536-555.
[78]陈卫东,边卫红,郝毅,等.石油美元环流演变、新能源金融发展与人民币国际化研究[J].国际金融研究,2020(12):3-12.

相似文献/References:

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:

收稿日期:2022-06-18
基金项目:国家社会科学基金项目(20BJL049); 国家自然科学基金项目(72001119,72103105)
作者简介:余子良(1985-),男,江苏徐州人,长任副教授,经济学博士。

常用功能

更新日期/Last Update: 2022-11-30