|Table of Contents|

Evaluation method for journal manuscript quality(PDF)

《长安大学学报（社科版）》[ISSN:1671-6248/CN:61-1391/C]

Issue:
2012年03期
Page:
116-119
Research Field:
编辑学
Publishing date:

Info

Title:
Evaluation method for journal manuscript quality
Author(s):
YUAN Hua-zhi;  HAN Yue-jie;  WU Ming-qian
Department of Magazines Publishing, Chang'an University, Xi'an 710064, Shaanxi, China
Keywords:
academic journal;  manuscript quality;  evaluation method;  fuzzy mathematics
PACS:
G232.1
DOI:
-
Abstract:
The deficiency of existing evaluation method for journal manuscript quality was analyzed. Based on the fuzzy evaluation method, Delphi method and AHP method were combined, and the analytic hierarchy model of manuscript quality was set up. The three indexes such as innovation, scientificalness and practicability were taken as rule layer, each of which was quantitatively treated with average weighted method. In this way, the comprehensive evaluation system of manuscript quality was set up, and the practical verification on journal A was carried out. The analysis result shows that with the proposed evaluation method for manuscript quality, the practical status of journal A can be truly reflected, and the theoretical basis can be provided for the further improvement of journal A.

References:

[1] 郭银巧.科技学术期刊稿件质量控制及其提升策略[J].农业图书情报学刊,2012,24(8):166-168.
[2]张凤新.科技期刊编辑在约稿环节的稿件质量控制与沟通技巧[J].科技与出版,2012(5):47-48.
[3]王 耀,华海清,孔 洁,等.科技期刊编辑对稿件的学术质量初审量化研究与应用[J].中国科技期刊研究,2012,23(1):146-149.
[4]蓝 华,于 渤.基于稿件质量的学术类科技期刊质量控制方法研究[J].中国科技期刊研究,2009,20(4):617-620.
[5]郑晓梅,刘 颖.科技期刊稿件编辑出版过程中的质量变异与过程质量控制[J].中国科技期刊研究,2007,18(6):964-966.
[6]郑晓梅,张维平.提高科技期刊稿件刊出质量的方法:事前、事中与事后控制[J].编辑学报,2006(增1):115-116.
[7]张 惠.论学术期刊编辑对稿件质量的把关:以文献引用为视角[J].出版科学,2011(2):42-45.
[8]焦新龙,刘雪莲,马天山.港口物流绩效定量评价理论及应用[J].经济地理,2009(12):2034-2038.
[9]赵志宏,孙守增.基于BP神经网络的稿件质量评价系统[J].中国科技期刊研究,2006,17(5):742-745.
[10]田 丽,谢新洲.网络科技论文质量评价研究[J].北京联合大学学报:人文社会科学版,2009,7(3):113-120.
[11]颜炳祥,任荣明,王漫天.中国区域汽车产业集群竞争力的AHP模糊评价[J].西南交通大学学报:社会科学版,2007,8(4):12-18.

Memo

Memo:
-
Last Update: 2012-09-20